{ "scaleVersion": "0.6", "workspace": { "id": "WS-NORTHSTAR", "name": "Northstar — Episode A investment decision", "status": "active", "leadBusinessArchitect": "Avery Chen", "exportId": "NORTHSTAR-A-20260109", "priorExportId": null, "exportedAt": "2026-01-09T17:00:00Z", "recordPurpose": "authored-fictional-example", "caseVersion": "1.2" }, "charter": { "businessQuestion": "What is the smallest defensible next commitment to improve customer service-promise reliability?", "decisionSupported": "Choose, condition, defer or reject A0–A4; separate learning, entry, expansion and procurement.", "decisionOwner": "Jordan Reed / ORG-13 Investment Council", "audience": [ "Investment Council", "Operations", "Finance", "Customer" ], "includedScope": [ "E-001–E-007", "Three candidate branch conditions", "Promise policy, reservation meaning, skills/capacity, exceptions and customer outcomes" ], "excludedScope": [ "Episode B/C evidence", "Enterprise rollout", "Vendor selection", "Committed ROI" ], "requiredWorkProduct": "Bounded decision brief and portable continuity record", "sufficiencyCondition": "Compare credible alternatives, uncertainty, cost/capacity and what would reverse the recommendation.", "stopCondition": "Stop modeling when detail cannot change the next commitment; redesign learning that cannot alter a decision.", "episode": "A", "evidenceCutoff": "2026-01-09T12:00:00Z" }, "evidence": [ { "id": "E-001", "title": "Operations dashboard and definitions", "owner": "ORG-09", "authority": "supporting-evidence", "location": "../case-study/episode-a/EVIDENCE-PACKET.md", "availableAt": "2026-01-05T09:00:00Z", "effectiveFrom": "2026-01-05", "effectiveTo": null, "reviewDate": "2026-01-30", "accessClass": "public-fictional", "claims": [ { "id": "E-001.1", "statement": "M-01 approximately 82% combines inconsistent local denominators.", "locator": "#e-001 / E-001.1" }, { "id": "E-001.2", "statement": "Metro uses latest accepted appointments and removes cancellations.", "locator": "#e-001 / E-001.2" }, { "id": "E-001.3", "statement": "Rural uses original window unless manager approves revision.", "locator": "#e-001 / E-001.3" }, { "id": "E-001.4", "statement": "Recovery records inconsistently link original commitment.", "locator": "#e-001 / E-001.4" } ], "limitations": [ "Not a reconciled pilot baseline; no approved customer restoration-time baseline." ], "disposition": "limited" }, { "id": "E-002", "title": "Regional quality sample", "owner": "ORG-07", "authority": "supporting-evidence", "location": "../case-study/episode-a/EVIDENCE-PACKET.md", "availableAt": "2026-01-06T09:00:00Z", "effectiveFrom": "2026-01-06", "effectiveTo": null, "reviewDate": "2026-01-30", "accessClass": "public-fictional", "claims": [ { "id": "E-002.1", "statement": "M-02 approximately 14% against an 8% aspiration.", "locator": "#e-002 / E-002.1" }, { "id": "E-002.2", "statement": "Regions dispute preventable-repeat coding.", "locator": "#e-002 / E-002.2" }, { "id": "E-002.3", "statement": "Sampling and event coding require validation before savings claims.", "locator": "#e-002 / E-002.3" } ], "limitations": [ "Disputed coding and sample frame; no causal estimate." ], "disposition": "limited" }, { "id": "E-003", "title": "Workshops and dispatcher observations", "owner": "Avery Chen / ORG-14", "authority": "supporting-evidence", "location": "../case-study/episode-a/EVIDENCE-PACKET.md", "availableAt": "2026-01-07T09:00:00Z", "effectiveFrom": "2026-01-07", "effectiveTo": null, "reviewDate": "2026-01-30", "accessClass": "public-fictional", "claims": [ { "id": "E-003.1", "statement": "Dates sometimes promised before physical part confirmation.", "locator": "#e-003 / E-003.1" }, { "id": "E-003.2", "statement": "Allocation, reservation, expiry and refresh have distinct meanings.", "locator": "#e-003 / E-003.2" }, { "id": "E-003.3", "statement": "Rural travel, skills and exception approval constrain dates.", "locator": "#e-003 / E-003.3" }, { "id": "E-003.4", "statement": "Later promises may improve reporting while worsening service.", "locator": "#e-003 / E-003.4" }, { "id": "E-003.5", "statement": "Identifiers/timestamps do not establish consistent source semantics.", "locator": "#e-003 / E-003.5" } ], "limitations": [ "Convergent observation, not a controlled causal study." ], "disposition": "limited" }, { "id": "E-004", "title": "Vendor demonstration and integration note", "owner": "ORG-11", "authority": "supporting-evidence", "location": "../case-study/episode-a/EVIDENCE-PACKET.md", "availableAt": "2026-01-08T09:00:00Z", "effectiveFrom": "2026-01-08", "effectiveTo": null, "reviewDate": "2026-01-30", "accessClass": "public-fictional", "claims": [ { "id": "E-004.1", "statement": "Demo blocked commitments with absent part/skill fields.", "locator": "#e-004 / E-004.1" }, { "id": "E-004.2", "statement": "No live feed, representative rural test, adoption or value experiment.", "locator": "#e-004 / E-004.2" }, { "id": "E-004.3", "statement": "Platform planning range $4–7m over 18–24 months, not accepted quote.", "locator": "#e-004 / E-004.3" }, { "id": "E-004.4", "statement": "A4 narrow feed/exception queue: $60–120k, 1–2 FTE, contingent on source semantics; not a scarcity/travel/policy solution.", "locator": "#e-004 / E-004.4" } ], "limitations": [ "Functionality is not fit/value; API availability is not integration feasibility." ], "disposition": "limited" }, { "id": "E-005", "title": "Finance planning memorandum", "owner": "Morgan Ellis / ORG-12", "authority": "governed-authority", "location": "../case-study/episode-a/EVIDENCE-PACKET.md", "availableAt": "2026-01-08T09:00:00Z", "effectiveFrom": "2026-01-08", "effectiveTo": null, "reviewDate": "2026-01-30", "accessClass": "public-fictional", "claims": [ { "id": "E-005.1", "statement": "Enterprise margin31%; proposed cumulative guardrail at least31%.", "locator": "#e-005 / E-005.1" }, { "id": "E-005.2", "statement": "Unvalidated gross recoverable credits/overtime $9–18k/month; excludes lost demand.", "locator": "#e-005 / E-005.2" }, { "id": "E-005.3", "statement": "90-day delay scenario $27–54k if other conditions hold; not ROI.", "locator": "#e-005 / E-005.3" }, { "id": "E-005.4", "statement": "A1 includes labor/training/participation/measurement; recurring burden separate.", "locator": "#e-005 / E-005.4" }, { "id": "E-005.5", "statement": "Resolve decision-changing uncertainty cheaply before material commitment.", "locator": "#e-005 / E-005.5" } ], "limitations": [ "Planning assumptions are neither achieved benefits nor causal estimates." ], "disposition": "limited" }, { "id": "E-006", "title": "Two-week commitment review", "owner": "ORG-09", "authority": "supporting-evidence", "location": "../case-study/episode-a/EVIDENCE-PACKET.md", "availableAt": "2026-01-08T09:00:00Z", "effectiveFrom": "2026-01-08", "effectiveTo": null, "reviewDate": "2026-01-30", "accessClass": "public-fictional", "claims": [ { "id": "E-006.1", "statement": "68/180 had recorded part/skill confirmation:37.8%.", "locator": "#e-006 / E-006.1" }, { "id": "E-006.2", "statement": "Six candidate branches differ from later eligible cohort.", "locator": "#e-006 / E-006.2" }, { "id": "E-006.3", "statement": "M-04 part/skill checks do not equal complete policy compliance.", "locator": "#e-006 / E-006.3" }, { "id": "E-006.4", "statement": "Missing evidence may be recording failure rather than missing action.", "locator": "#e-006 / E-006.4" } ], "limitations": [ "Purposive sample; cannot annualize or reuse as the pilot baseline." ], "disposition": "limited" }, { "id": "E-007", "title": "Branch capacity and options worksheet", "owner": "ORG-05 / Finance / Delivery", "authority": "supporting-evidence", "location": "../case-study/episode-a/EVIDENCE-PACKET.md", "availableAt": "2026-01-09T09:00:00Z", "effectiveFrom": "2026-01-09", "effectiveTo": null, "reviewDate": "2026-01-30", "accessClass": "public-fictional", "claims": [ { "id": "E-007.1", "statement": "Five-day diagnostic within $15k included in eventual A1 cap.", "locator": "#e-007 / E-007.1" }, { "id": "E-007.2", "statement": "Proposed cumulative stages:$15k diagnostic,$75k preparation,$300k after entry.", "locator": "#e-007 / E-007.2" }, { "id": "E-007.3", "statement": "Proposed productivity,cost/capacity/customer guards and original/restoration measures.", "locator": "#e-007 / E-007.3" }, { "id": "E-007.4", "statement": "Readiness,customer harm and source authority may stop a test after analysis is sufficient.", "locator": "#e-007 / E-007.4" } ], "limitations": [ "Three purposively selected branches do not establish representativeness; cost/capacity provisional." ], "disposition": "limited" } ], "elements": [ { "id": "O-01", "version": 1, "status": "accepted", "owner": "ORG-09", "scope": "Fictional Northstar Episode A decision; accepted for this engagement only.", "effectiveFrom": "2026-01-09", "effectiveTo": null, "reviewDate": "2026-01-30", "accessClass": "public-fictional", "classification": "fact", "confidence": "high", "confidenceBasis": "Supplied case definition reviewed for this scope, not evidence of an achieved outcome.", "evidenceLinks": [], "sourceRefs": [ { "location": "../case-study/episode-a/EVIDENCE-PACKET.md", "locator": "#existing-architecture-fragments", "supports": "Supplied architecture identifier and definition." } ], "reviewId": "REV-A-ELEMENTS", "supersedes": null, "type": "objective", "name": "Reliable service promises", "definition": "Reliable promises with usable branch discretion." }, { "id": "O-02", "version": 1, "status": "accepted", "owner": "ORG-12", "scope": "Fictional Northstar Episode A decision; accepted for this engagement only.", "effectiveFrom": "2026-01-09", "effectiveTo": null, "reviewDate": "2026-01-30", "accessClass": "public-fictional", "classification": "fact", "confidence": "high", "confidenceBasis": "Supplied case definition reviewed for this scope, not evidence of an achieved outcome.", "evidenceLinks": [], "sourceRefs": [ { "location": "../case-study/episode-a/EVIDENCE-PACKET.md", "locator": "#existing-architecture-fragments", "supports": "Supplied architecture identifier and definition." } ], "reviewId": "REV-A-ELEMENTS", "supersedes": null, "type": "objective", "name": "Protect service margin", "definition": "Avoid transferring reliability gains into margin loss." }, { "id": "O-03", "version": 1, "status": "accepted", "owner": "ORG-09", "scope": "Fictional Northstar Episode A decision; accepted for this engagement only.", "effectiveFrom": "2026-01-09", "effectiveTo": null, "reviewDate": "2026-01-30", "accessClass": "public-fictional", "classification": "fact", "confidence": "high", "confidenceBasis": "Supplied case definition reviewed for this scope, not evidence of an achieved outcome.", "evidenceLinks": [], "sourceRefs": [ { "location": "../case-study/episode-a/EVIDENCE-PACKET.md", "locator": "#existing-architecture-fragments", "supports": "Supplied architecture identifier and definition." } ], "reviewId": "REV-A-ELEMENTS", "supersedes": null, "type": "objective", "name": "Reduce customer disruption", "definition": "Reduce avoidable disruption and repeat work; equipment availability matters." }, { "id": "VS-01", "version": 1, "status": "accepted", "owner": "ORG-09", "scope": "Fictional Northstar Episode A decision; accepted for this engagement only.", "effectiveFrom": "2026-01-09", "effectiveTo": null, "reviewDate": "2026-01-30", "accessClass": "public-fictional", "classification": "fact", "confidence": "high", "confidenceBasis": "Supplied case definition reviewed for this scope, not evidence of an achieved outcome.", "evidenceLinks": [], "sourceRefs": [ { "location": "../case-study/episode-a/EVIDENCE-PACKET.md", "locator": "#existing-architecture-fragments", "supports": "Supplied architecture identifier and definition." } ], "reviewId": "REV-A-ELEMENTS", "supersedes": null, "type": "value-stream", "name": "Restore Equipment Availability", "definition": "Customer value is usable equipment, not a kept revised appointment." }, { "id": "ST-02", "version": 1, "status": "accepted", "owner": "ORG-09", "scope": "Fictional Northstar Episode A decision; accepted for this engagement only.", "effectiveFrom": "2026-01-09", "effectiveTo": null, "reviewDate": "2026-01-30", "accessClass": "public-fictional", "classification": "fact", "confidence": "high", "confidenceBasis": "Supplied case definition reviewed for this scope, not evidence of an achieved outcome.", "evidenceLinks": [], "sourceRefs": [ { "location": "../case-study/episode-a/EVIDENCE-PACKET.md", "locator": "#existing-architecture-fragments", "supports": "Supplied architecture identifier and definition." } ], "reviewId": "REV-A-ELEMENTS", "supersedes": null, "type": "value-stream-stage", "name": "Define service promise", "definition": "Convert accepted need into an understood feasible commitment." }, { "id": "C-110", "version": 1, "status": "accepted", "owner": "ORG-09", "scope": "Fictional Northstar Episode A decision; accepted for this engagement only.", "effectiveFrom": "2026-01-09", "effectiveTo": null, "reviewDate": "2026-01-30", "accessClass": "public-fictional", "classification": "fact", "confidence": "high", "confidenceBasis": "Supplied case definition reviewed for this scope, not evidence of an achieved outcome.", "evidenceLinks": [], "sourceRefs": [ { "location": "../case-study/episode-a/EVIDENCE-PACKET.md", "locator": "#existing-architecture-fragments", "supports": "Supplied architecture identifier and definition." } ], "reviewId": "REV-A-ELEMENTS", "supersedes": null, "type": "capability", "name": "Service Promise Management", "definition": "Govern commitments using resource signals; does not schedule technicians or reserve parts." }, { "id": "C-130", "version": 1, "status": "accepted", "owner": "ORG-05", "scope": "Fictional Northstar Episode A decision; accepted for this engagement only.", "effectiveFrom": "2026-01-09", "effectiveTo": null, "reviewDate": "2026-01-30", "accessClass": "public-fictional", "classification": "fact", "confidence": "high", "confidenceBasis": "Supplied case definition reviewed for this scope, not evidence of an achieved outcome.", "evidenceLinks": [], "sourceRefs": [ { "location": "../case-study/episode-a/EVIDENCE-PACKET.md", "locator": "#existing-architecture-fragments", "supports": "Supplied architecture identifier and definition." } ], "reviewId": "REV-A-ELEMENTS", "supersedes": null, "type": "capability", "name": "Resource Scheduling", "definition": "Match work to qualified people, time, geography and capacity." }, { "id": "C-140", "version": 1, "status": "accepted", "owner": "ORG-08", "scope": "Fictional Northstar Episode A decision; accepted for this engagement only.", "effectiveFrom": "2026-01-09", "effectiveTo": null, "reviewDate": "2026-01-30", "accessClass": "public-fictional", "classification": "fact", "confidence": "high", "confidenceBasis": "Supplied case definition reviewed for this scope, not evidence of an achieved outcome.", "evidenceLinks": [], "sourceRefs": [ { "location": "../case-study/episode-a/EVIDENCE-PACKET.md", "locator": "#existing-architecture-fragments", "supports": "Supplied architecture identifier and definition." } ], "reviewId": "REV-A-ELEMENTS", "supersedes": null, "type": "capability", "name": "Parts Availability Management", "definition": "Determine,reserve,position,consume,release and expire availability." }, { "id": "C-170", "version": 1, "status": "accepted", "owner": "ORG-09", "scope": "Fictional Northstar Episode A decision; accepted for this engagement only.", "effectiveFrom": "2026-01-09", "effectiveTo": null, "reviewDate": "2026-01-30", "accessClass": "public-fictional", "classification": "fact", "confidence": "high", "confidenceBasis": "Supplied case definition reviewed for this scope, not evidence of an achieved outcome.", "evidenceLinks": [], "sourceRefs": [ { "location": "../case-study/episode-a/EVIDENCE-PACKET.md", "locator": "#existing-architecture-fragments", "supports": "Supplied architecture identifier and definition." } ], "reviewId": "REV-A-ELEMENTS", "supersedes": null, "type": "capability", "name": "Service Performance Management", "definition": "Define and explain measures without acquiring Finance authority." }, { "id": "C-180", "version": 1, "status": "accepted", "owner": "ORG-10", "scope": "Fictional Northstar Episode A decision; accepted for this engagement only.", "effectiveFrom": "2026-01-09", "effectiveTo": null, "reviewDate": "2026-01-30", "accessClass": "public-fictional", "classification": "fact", "confidence": "high", "confidenceBasis": "Supplied case definition reviewed for this scope, not evidence of an achieved outcome.", "evidenceLinks": [], "sourceRefs": [ { "location": "../case-study/episode-a/EVIDENCE-PACKET.md", "locator": "#existing-architecture-fragments", "supports": "Supplied architecture identifier and definition." } ], "reviewId": "REV-A-ELEMENTS", "supersedes": null, "type": "capability", "name": "Business Information Governance", "definition": "Govern meaning,ownership,quality and semantic change." }, { "id": "BO-02", "version": 1, "status": "accepted", "owner": "ORG-09", "scope": "Fictional Northstar Episode A decision; accepted for this engagement only.", "effectiveFrom": "2026-01-09", "effectiveTo": null, "reviewDate": "2026-01-30", "accessClass": "public-fictional", "classification": "fact", "confidence": "high", "confidenceBasis": "Supplied case definition reviewed for this scope, not evidence of an achieved outcome.", "evidenceLinks": [], "sourceRefs": [ { "location": "../case-study/episode-a/EVIDENCE-PACKET.md", "locator": "#existing-architecture-fragments", "supports": "Supplied architecture identifier and definition." } ], "reviewId": "REV-A-ELEMENTS", "supersedes": null, "type": "business-object", "name": "Customer Promise", "definition": "Versioned commitment retaining original and revised promises." }, { "id": "BO-05", "version": 1, "status": "accepted", "owner": "Unresolved: ORG-08 proposed; OI-02", "scope": "Fictional Northstar Episode A decision; accepted for this engagement only.", "effectiveFrom": "2026-01-09", "effectiveTo": null, "reviewDate": "2026-01-30", "accessClass": "public-fictional", "classification": "unknown", "confidence": "insufficient", "confidenceBasis": "Object identified; owner/source unresolved.", "evidenceLinks": [], "sourceRefs": [ { "location": "../case-study/episode-a/EVIDENCE-PACKET.md", "locator": "#existing-architecture-fragments", "supports": "Supplied architecture identifier and definition." } ], "reviewId": "REV-A-ELEMENTS", "supersedes": null, "type": "business-object", "name": "Part Reservation", "definition": "Reservation state and expiry; owner and source authority unresolved." }, { "id": "BO-06", "version": 1, "status": "accepted", "owner": "ORG-05", "scope": "Fictional Northstar Episode A decision; accepted for this engagement only.", "effectiveFrom": "2026-01-09", "effectiveTo": null, "reviewDate": "2026-01-30", "accessClass": "public-fictional", "classification": "fact", "confidence": "high", "confidenceBasis": "Supplied case definition reviewed for this scope, not evidence of an achieved outcome.", "evidenceLinks": [], "sourceRefs": [ { "location": "../case-study/episode-a/EVIDENCE-PACKET.md", "locator": "#existing-architecture-fragments", "supports": "Supplied architecture identifier and definition." } ], "reviewId": "REV-A-ELEMENTS", "supersedes": null, "type": "business-object", "name": "Technician Assignment", "definition": "Skill qualification and assignment acceptance are separate checks." }, { "id": "I-01", "version": 1, "status": "accepted", "owner": "ORG-09", "scope": "Fictional Northstar Episode A decision; accepted for this engagement only.", "effectiveFrom": "2026-01-09", "effectiveTo": null, "reviewDate": "2026-01-30", "accessClass": "public-fictional", "classification": "fact", "confidence": "high", "confidenceBasis": "Supplied case definition reviewed for this scope, not evidence of an achieved outcome.", "evidenceLinks": [], "sourceRefs": [ { "location": "../case-study/episode-a/EVIDENCE-PACKET.md", "locator": "#existing-architecture-fragments", "supports": "Supplied architecture identifier and definition." } ], "reviewId": "REV-A-ELEMENTS", "supersedes": null, "type": "initiative", "name": "Connected Service Promise", "definition": "Proposed bounded business change, not approved technology." }, { "id": "R1", "version": 1, "status": "accepted", "owner": "ORG-13", "scope": "Fictional Northstar Episode A decision; accepted for this engagement only.", "effectiveFrom": "2026-01-09", "effectiveTo": null, "reviewDate": "2026-01-30", "accessClass": "public-fictional", "classification": "recommendation", "confidence": "medium", "confidenceBasis": "Accepted as proposed design for comparison; operational approval remains separate.", "evidenceLinks": [], "sourceRefs": [ { "location": "../case-study/episode-a/EVIDENCE-PACKET.md", "locator": "#e-007", "supports": "Proposed operating experiment and guards." } ], "reviewId": "REV-A-ELEMENTS", "supersedes": null, "type": "release", "name": "Three-branch feasibility experiment", "definition": "Conditional test with staged investment and separate readiness." }, { "id": "M-01", "version": 1, "status": "accepted", "owner": "ORG-09", "scope": "Fictional Northstar Episode A decision; accepted for this engagement only.", "effectiveFrom": "2026-01-09", "effectiveTo": null, "reviewDate": "2026-01-30", "accessClass": "public-fictional", "classification": "fact", "confidence": "high", "confidenceBasis": "Supplied case definition reviewed for this scope, not evidence of an achieved outcome.", "evidenceLinks": [], "sourceRefs": [ { "location": "../case-study/episode-a/EVIDENCE-PACKET.md", "locator": "#existing-architecture-fragments", "supports": "Supplied architecture identifier and definition." } ], "reviewId": "REV-A-ELEMENTS", "supersedes": null, "type": "measure", "name": "Promise adherence", "definition": "Original/latest promise,eligibility and cancellation rules require reconciliation." }, { "id": "M-02", "version": 1, "status": "accepted", "owner": "ORG-07", "scope": "Fictional Northstar Episode A decision; accepted for this engagement only.", "effectiveFrom": "2026-01-09", "effectiveTo": null, "reviewDate": "2026-01-30", "accessClass": "public-fictional", "classification": "fact", "confidence": "high", "confidenceBasis": "Supplied case definition reviewed for this scope, not evidence of an achieved outcome.", "evidenceLinks": [], "sourceRefs": [ { "location": "../case-study/episode-a/EVIDENCE-PACKET.md", "locator": "#existing-architecture-fragments", "supports": "Supplied architecture identifier and definition." } ], "reviewId": "REV-A-ELEMENTS", "supersedes": null, "type": "measure", "name": "Avoidable repeat visits", "definition": "Repeat visits with disputed preventable-cause coding." }, { "id": "M-03", "version": 1, "status": "accepted", "owner": "ORG-12", "scope": "Fictional Northstar Episode A decision; accepted for this engagement only.", "effectiveFrom": "2026-01-09", "effectiveTo": null, "reviewDate": "2026-01-30", "accessClass": "public-fictional", "classification": "fact", "confidence": "high", "confidenceBasis": "Supplied case definition reviewed for this scope, not evidence of an achieved outcome.", "evidenceLinks": [], "sourceRefs": [ { "location": "../case-study/episode-a/EVIDENCE-PACKET.md", "locator": "#existing-architecture-fragments", "supports": "Supplied architecture identifier and definition." } ], "reviewId": "REV-A-ELEMENTS", "supersedes": null, "type": "measure", "name": "Gross service margin", "definition": "Finance-governed cumulative margin and work-mix interpretation." }, { "id": "M-04", "version": 1, "status": "accepted", "owner": "ORG-09", "scope": "Fictional Northstar Episode A decision; accepted for this engagement only.", "effectiveFrom": "2026-01-09", "effectiveTo": null, "reviewDate": "2026-01-30", "accessClass": "public-fictional", "classification": "fact", "confidence": "high", "confidenceBasis": "Supplied case definition reviewed for this scope, not evidence of an achieved outcome.", "evidenceLinks": [], "sourceRefs": [ { "location": "../case-study/episode-a/EVIDENCE-PACKET.md", "locator": "#existing-architecture-fragments", "supports": "Supplied architecture identifier and definition." } ], "reviewId": "REV-A-ELEMENTS", "supersedes": null, "type": "measure", "name": "Part/skill confirmation", "definition": "Pre-commitment part/skill recording, not full policy compliance." }, { "id": "M-06", "version": 1, "status": "accepted", "owner": "ORG-07", "scope": "Fictional Northstar Episode A decision; accepted for this engagement only.", "effectiveFrom": "2026-01-09", "effectiveTo": null, "reviewDate": "2026-01-30", "accessClass": "public-fictional", "classification": "fact", "confidence": "high", "confidenceBasis": "Supplied case definition reviewed for this scope, not evidence of an achieved outcome.", "evidenceLinks": [], "sourceRefs": [ { "location": "../case-study/episode-a/EVIDENCE-PACKET.md", "locator": "#existing-architecture-fragments", "supports": "Supplied architecture identifier and definition." } ], "reviewId": "REV-A-ELEMENTS", "supersedes": null, "type": "measure", "name": "Field productivity", "definition": "Productivity deterioration with work-mix explanation." }, { "id": "M-07", "version": 1, "status": "accepted", "owner": "ORG-09", "scope": "Fictional Northstar Episode A decision; accepted for this engagement only.", "effectiveFrom": "2026-01-09", "effectiveTo": null, "reviewDate": "2026-01-30", "accessClass": "public-fictional", "classification": "fact", "confidence": "high", "confidenceBasis": "Supplied case definition reviewed for this scope, not evidence of an achieved outcome.", "evidenceLinks": [], "sourceRefs": [ { "location": "../case-study/episode-a/EVIDENCE-PACKET.md", "locator": "#existing-architecture-fragments", "supports": "Supplied architecture identifier and definition." } ], "reviewId": "REV-A-ELEMENTS", "supersedes": null, "type": "measure", "name": "Policy adoption", "definition": "Complete workflow including valid approved exceptions." }, { "id": "M-08", "version": 1, "status": "accepted", "owner": "ORG-12", "scope": "Fictional Northstar Episode A decision; accepted for this engagement only.", "effectiveFrom": "2026-01-09", "effectiveTo": null, "reviewDate": "2026-01-30", "accessClass": "public-fictional", "classification": "fact", "confidence": "high", "confidenceBasis": "Supplied case definition reviewed for this scope, not evidence of an achieved outcome.", "evidenceLinks": [], "sourceRefs": [ { "location": "../case-study/episode-a/EVIDENCE-PACKET.md", "locator": "#existing-architecture-fragments", "supports": "Supplied architecture identifier and definition." } ], "reviewId": "REV-A-ELEMENTS", "supersedes": null, "type": "measure", "name": "Cost and capacity", "definition": "Fully loaded cumulative cost and peak temporary FTE." }, { "id": "POL-01", "version": 1, "status": "accepted", "owner": "ORG-09", "scope": "Fictional Northstar Episode A decision; accepted for this engagement only.", "effectiveFrom": "2026-01-09", "effectiveTo": null, "reviewDate": "2026-01-30", "accessClass": "public-fictional", "classification": "recommendation", "confidence": "medium", "confidenceBasis": "Accepted as proposed design for comparison; operational approval remains separate.", "evidenceLinks": [], "sourceRefs": [ { "location": "../case-study/episode-a/EVIDENCE-PACKET.md", "locator": "#e-007", "supports": "Proposed operating experiment and guards." } ], "reviewId": "REV-A-ELEMENTS", "supersedes": null, "type": "policy", "name": "Service Promise Policy", "definition": "Proposed confirmation,exception,change,communication and recovery rules." } ], "relationships": [ { "id": "RL-001", "version": 1, "status": "accepted", "owner": "Avery Chen / architecture stewardship", "scope": "Fictional Northstar Episode A decision; accepted for this engagement only.", "effectiveFrom": "2026-01-09", "effectiveTo": null, "reviewDate": "2026-01-30", "accessClass": "public-fictional", "classification": "inference", "confidence": "medium", "confidenceBasis": "Typed bounded inference/design, not causal proof or operating authorization.", "evidenceLinks": [], "sourceRefs": [ { "location": "../case-study/episode-a/EVIDENCE-PACKET.md", "locator": "#existing-architecture-fragments", "supports": "Supplied architecture identifier and definition." } ], "reviewId": "REV-A-RELATIONSHIPS", "supersedes": null, "sourceId": "O-01", "type": "guides", "targetId": "VS-01" }, { "id": "RL-002", "version": 1, "status": "accepted", "owner": "Avery Chen / architecture stewardship", "scope": "Fictional Northstar Episode A decision; accepted for this engagement only.", "effectiveFrom": "2026-01-09", "effectiveTo": null, "reviewDate": "2026-01-30", "accessClass": "public-fictional", "classification": "inference", "confidence": "medium", "confidenceBasis": "Typed bounded inference/design, not causal proof or operating authorization.", "evidenceLinks": [], "sourceRefs": [ { "location": "../case-study/episode-a/EVIDENCE-PACKET.md", "locator": "#existing-architecture-fragments", "supports": "Supplied architecture identifier and definition." } ], "reviewId": "REV-A-RELATIONSHIPS", "supersedes": null, "sourceId": "O-03", "type": "guides", "targetId": "VS-01" }, { "id": "RL-003", "version": 1, "status": "accepted", "owner": "Avery Chen / architecture stewardship", "scope": "Fictional Northstar Episode A decision; accepted for this engagement only.", "effectiveFrom": "2026-01-09", "effectiveTo": null, "reviewDate": "2026-01-30", "accessClass": "public-fictional", "classification": "inference", "confidence": "medium", "confidenceBasis": "Typed bounded inference/design, not causal proof or operating authorization.", "evidenceLinks": [], "sourceRefs": [ { "location": "../case-study/episode-a/EVIDENCE-PACKET.md", "locator": "#existing-architecture-fragments", "supports": "Supplied architecture identifier and definition." } ], "reviewId": "REV-A-RELATIONSHIPS", "supersedes": null, "sourceId": "VS-01", "type": "contains", "targetId": "ST-02" }, { "id": "RL-004", "version": 1, "status": "accepted", "owner": "Avery Chen / architecture stewardship", "scope": "Fictional Northstar Episode A decision; accepted for this engagement only.", "effectiveFrom": "2026-01-09", "effectiveTo": null, "reviewDate": "2026-01-30", "accessClass": "public-fictional", "classification": "inference", "confidence": "medium", "confidenceBasis": "Typed bounded inference/design, not causal proof or operating authorization.", "evidenceLinks": [], "sourceRefs": [ { "location": "../case-study/episode-a/EVIDENCE-PACKET.md", "locator": "#existing-architecture-fragments", "supports": "Supplied architecture identifier and definition." } ], "reviewId": "REV-A-RELATIONSHIPS", "supersedes": null, "sourceId": "C-110", "type": "enables", "targetId": "ST-02" }, { "id": "RL-005", "version": 1, "status": "accepted", "owner": "Avery Chen / architecture stewardship", "scope": "Fictional Northstar Episode A decision; accepted for this engagement only.", "effectiveFrom": "2026-01-09", "effectiveTo": null, "reviewDate": "2026-01-30", "accessClass": "public-fictional", "classification": "inference", "confidence": "medium", "confidenceBasis": "Typed bounded inference/design, not causal proof or operating authorization.", "evidenceLinks": [], "sourceRefs": [ { "location": "../case-study/episode-a/EVIDENCE-PACKET.md", "locator": "#existing-architecture-fragments", "supports": "Supplied architecture identifier and definition." } ], "reviewId": "REV-A-RELATIONSHIPS", "supersedes": null, "sourceId": "C-130", "type": "supplies-signal-to", "targetId": "C-110" }, { "id": "RL-006", "version": 1, "status": "accepted", "owner": "Avery Chen / architecture stewardship", "scope": "Fictional Northstar Episode A decision; accepted for this engagement only.", "effectiveFrom": "2026-01-09", "effectiveTo": null, "reviewDate": "2026-01-30", "accessClass": "public-fictional", "classification": "inference", "confidence": "medium", "confidenceBasis": "Typed bounded inference/design, not causal proof or operating authorization.", "evidenceLinks": [], "sourceRefs": [ { "location": "../case-study/episode-a/EVIDENCE-PACKET.md", "locator": "#existing-architecture-fragments", "supports": "Supplied architecture identifier and definition." } ], "reviewId": "REV-A-RELATIONSHIPS", "supersedes": null, "sourceId": "C-140", "type": "supplies-signal-to", "targetId": "C-110" }, { "id": "RL-007", "version": 1, "status": "accepted", "owner": "Avery Chen / architecture stewardship", "scope": "Fictional Northstar Episode A decision; accepted for this engagement only.", "effectiveFrom": "2026-01-09", "effectiveTo": null, "reviewDate": "2026-01-30", "accessClass": "public-fictional", "classification": "inference", "confidence": "medium", "confidenceBasis": "Typed bounded inference/design, not causal proof or operating authorization.", "evidenceLinks": [], "sourceRefs": [ { "location": "../case-study/episode-a/EVIDENCE-PACKET.md", "locator": "#existing-architecture-fragments", "supports": "Supplied architecture identifier and definition." } ], "reviewId": "REV-A-RELATIONSHIPS", "supersedes": null, "sourceId": "C-110", "type": "governs", "targetId": "BO-02" }, { "id": "RL-008", "version": 1, "status": "accepted", "owner": "Avery Chen / architecture stewardship", "scope": "Fictional Northstar Episode A decision; accepted for this engagement only.", "effectiveFrom": "2026-01-09", "effectiveTo": null, "reviewDate": "2026-01-30", "accessClass": "public-fictional", "classification": "inference", "confidence": "medium", "confidenceBasis": "Typed bounded inference/design, not causal proof or operating authorization.", "evidenceLinks": [], "sourceRefs": [ { "location": "../case-study/episode-a/EVIDENCE-PACKET.md", "locator": "#existing-architecture-fragments", "supports": "Supplied architecture identifier and definition." } ], "reviewId": "REV-A-RELATIONSHIPS", "supersedes": null, "sourceId": "C-140", "type": "governs", "targetId": "BO-05" }, { "id": "RL-009", "version": 1, "status": "accepted", "owner": "Avery Chen / architecture stewardship", "scope": "Fictional Northstar Episode A decision; accepted for this engagement only.", "effectiveFrom": "2026-01-09", "effectiveTo": null, "reviewDate": "2026-01-30", "accessClass": "public-fictional", "classification": "inference", "confidence": "medium", "confidenceBasis": "Typed bounded inference/design, not causal proof or operating authorization.", "evidenceLinks": [], "sourceRefs": [ { "location": "../case-study/episode-a/EVIDENCE-PACKET.md", "locator": "#existing-architecture-fragments", "supports": "Supplied architecture identifier and definition." } ], "reviewId": "REV-A-RELATIONSHIPS", "supersedes": null, "sourceId": "C-130", "type": "governs", "targetId": "BO-06" }, { "id": "RL-010", "version": 1, "status": "accepted", "owner": "Avery Chen / architecture stewardship", "scope": "Fictional Northstar Episode A decision; accepted for this engagement only.", "effectiveFrom": "2026-01-09", "effectiveTo": null, "reviewDate": "2026-01-30", "accessClass": "public-fictional", "classification": "inference", "confidence": "medium", "confidenceBasis": "Typed bounded inference/design, not causal proof or operating authorization.", "evidenceLinks": [], "sourceRefs": [ { "location": "../case-study/episode-a/EVIDENCE-PACKET.md", "locator": "#existing-architecture-fragments", "supports": "Supplied architecture identifier and definition." } ], "reviewId": "REV-A-RELATIONSHIPS", "supersedes": null, "sourceId": "C-170", "type": "measures", "targetId": "M-01" }, { "id": "RL-011", "version": 1, "status": "accepted", "owner": "Avery Chen / architecture stewardship", "scope": "Fictional Northstar Episode A decision; accepted for this engagement only.", "effectiveFrom": "2026-01-09", "effectiveTo": null, "reviewDate": "2026-01-30", "accessClass": "public-fictional", "classification": "inference", "confidence": "medium", "confidenceBasis": "Typed bounded inference/design, not causal proof or operating authorization.", "evidenceLinks": [], "sourceRefs": [ { "location": "../case-study/episode-a/EVIDENCE-PACKET.md", "locator": "#existing-architecture-fragments", "supports": "Supplied architecture identifier and definition." } ], "reviewId": "REV-A-RELATIONSHIPS", "supersedes": null, "sourceId": "C-170", "type": "measures", "targetId": "M-04" }, { "id": "RL-012", "version": 1, "status": "accepted", "owner": "Avery Chen / architecture stewardship", "scope": "Fictional Northstar Episode A decision; accepted for this engagement only.", "effectiveFrom": "2026-01-09", "effectiveTo": null, "reviewDate": "2026-01-30", "accessClass": "public-fictional", "classification": "recommendation", "confidence": "medium", "confidenceBasis": "Typed bounded inference/design, not causal proof or operating authorization.", "evidenceLinks": [], "sourceRefs": [ { "location": "../case-study/episode-a/EVIDENCE-PACKET.md", "locator": "#existing-architecture-fragments", "supports": "Supplied architecture identifier and definition." } ], "reviewId": "REV-A-RELATIONSHIPS", "supersedes": null, "sourceId": "R1", "type": "changes", "targetId": "C-110" }, { "id": "RL-013", "version": 1, "status": "accepted", "owner": "Avery Chen / architecture stewardship", "scope": "Fictional Northstar Episode A decision; accepted for this engagement only.", "effectiveFrom": "2026-01-09", "effectiveTo": null, "reviewDate": "2026-01-30", "accessClass": "public-fictional", "classification": "recommendation", "confidence": "medium", "confidenceBasis": "Typed bounded inference/design, not causal proof or operating authorization.", "evidenceLinks": [], "sourceRefs": [ { "location": "../case-study/episode-a/EVIDENCE-PACKET.md", "locator": "#existing-architecture-fragments", "supports": "Supplied architecture identifier and definition." } ], "reviewId": "REV-A-RELATIONSHIPS", "supersedes": null, "sourceId": "R1", "type": "changes", "targetId": "C-130" }, { "id": "RL-014", "version": 1, "status": "accepted", "owner": "Avery Chen / architecture stewardship", "scope": "Fictional Northstar Episode A decision; accepted for this engagement only.", "effectiveFrom": "2026-01-09", "effectiveTo": null, "reviewDate": "2026-01-30", "accessClass": "public-fictional", "classification": "recommendation", "confidence": "medium", "confidenceBasis": "Typed bounded inference/design, not causal proof or operating authorization.", "evidenceLinks": [], "sourceRefs": [ { "location": "../case-study/episode-a/EVIDENCE-PACKET.md", "locator": "#existing-architecture-fragments", "supports": "Supplied architecture identifier and definition." } ], "reviewId": "REV-A-RELATIONSHIPS", "supersedes": null, "sourceId": "R1", "type": "changes", "targetId": "C-140" }, { "id": "RL-015", "version": 1, "status": "accepted", "owner": "Avery Chen / architecture stewardship", "scope": "Fictional Northstar Episode A decision; accepted for this engagement only.", "effectiveFrom": "2026-01-09", "effectiveTo": null, "reviewDate": "2026-01-30", "accessClass": "public-fictional", "classification": "recommendation", "confidence": "medium", "confidenceBasis": "Typed bounded inference/design, not causal proof or operating authorization.", "evidenceLinks": [], "sourceRefs": [ { "location": "../case-study/episode-a/EVIDENCE-PACKET.md", "locator": "#existing-architecture-fragments", "supports": "Supplied architecture identifier and definition." } ], "reviewId": "REV-A-RELATIONSHIPS", "supersedes": null, "sourceId": "R1", "type": "changes", "targetId": "C-170" }, { "id": "RL-016", "version": 1, "status": "accepted", "owner": "Avery Chen / architecture stewardship", "scope": "Fictional Northstar Episode A decision; accepted for this engagement only.", "effectiveFrom": "2026-01-09", "effectiveTo": null, "reviewDate": "2026-01-30", "accessClass": "public-fictional", "classification": "recommendation", "confidence": "medium", "confidenceBasis": "Typed bounded inference/design, not causal proof or operating authorization.", "evidenceLinks": [], "sourceRefs": [ { "location": "../case-study/episode-a/EVIDENCE-PACKET.md", "locator": "#existing-architecture-fragments", "supports": "Supplied architecture identifier and definition." } ], "reviewId": "REV-A-RELATIONSHIPS", "supersedes": null, "sourceId": "R1", "type": "changes", "targetId": "C-180" }, { "id": "RL-017", "version": 1, "status": "accepted", "owner": "Avery Chen / architecture stewardship", "scope": "Fictional Northstar Episode A decision; accepted for this engagement only.", "effectiveFrom": "2026-01-09", "effectiveTo": null, "reviewDate": "2026-01-30", "accessClass": "public-fictional", "classification": "recommendation", "confidence": "medium", "confidenceBasis": "Typed bounded inference/design, not causal proof or operating authorization.", "evidenceLinks": [], "sourceRefs": [ { "location": "../case-study/episode-a/EVIDENCE-PACKET.md", "locator": "#existing-architecture-fragments", "supports": "Supplied architecture identifier and definition." } ], "reviewId": "REV-A-RELATIONSHIPS", "supersedes": null, "sourceId": "R1", "type": "part-of", "targetId": "I-01" }, { "id": "RL-018", "version": 1, "status": "accepted", "owner": "Avery Chen / architecture stewardship", "scope": "Fictional Northstar Episode A decision; accepted for this engagement only.", "effectiveFrom": "2026-01-09", "effectiveTo": null, "reviewDate": "2026-01-30", "accessClass": "public-fictional", "classification": "inference", "confidence": "medium", "confidenceBasis": "Typed bounded inference/design, not causal proof or operating authorization.", "evidenceLinks": [], "sourceRefs": [ { "location": "../case-study/episode-a/EVIDENCE-PACKET.md", "locator": "#existing-architecture-fragments", "supports": "Supplied architecture identifier and definition." } ], "reviewId": "REV-A-RELATIONSHIPS", "supersedes": null, "sourceId": "M-01", "type": "evaluates", "targetId": "O-01" }, { "id": "RL-019", "version": 1, "status": "accepted", "owner": "Avery Chen / architecture stewardship", "scope": "Fictional Northstar Episode A decision; accepted for this engagement only.", "effectiveFrom": "2026-01-09", "effectiveTo": null, "reviewDate": "2026-01-30", "accessClass": "public-fictional", "classification": "inference", "confidence": "medium", "confidenceBasis": "Typed bounded inference/design, not causal proof or operating authorization.", "evidenceLinks": [], "sourceRefs": [ { "location": "../case-study/episode-a/EVIDENCE-PACKET.md", "locator": "#existing-architecture-fragments", "supports": "Supplied architecture identifier and definition." } ], "reviewId": "REV-A-RELATIONSHIPS", "supersedes": null, "sourceId": "M-03", "type": "evaluates", "targetId": "O-02" }, { "id": "RL-020", "version": 1, "status": "accepted", "owner": "Avery Chen / architecture stewardship", "scope": "Fictional Northstar Episode A decision; accepted for this engagement only.", "effectiveFrom": "2026-01-09", "effectiveTo": null, "reviewDate": "2026-01-30", "accessClass": "public-fictional", "classification": "inference", "confidence": "medium", "confidenceBasis": "Typed bounded inference/design, not causal proof or operating authorization.", "evidenceLinks": [], "sourceRefs": [ { "location": "../case-study/episode-a/EVIDENCE-PACKET.md", "locator": "#existing-architecture-fragments", "supports": "Supplied architecture identifier and definition." } ], "reviewId": "REV-A-RELATIONSHIPS", "supersedes": null, "sourceId": "M-02", "type": "evaluates", "targetId": "O-03" }, { "id": "RL-021", "version": 1, "status": "accepted", "owner": "Avery Chen / architecture stewardship", "scope": "Fictional Northstar Episode A decision; accepted for this engagement only.", "effectiveFrom": "2026-01-09", "effectiveTo": null, "reviewDate": "2026-01-30", "accessClass": "public-fictional", "classification": "inference", "confidence": "medium", "confidenceBasis": "Typed bounded inference/design, not causal proof or operating authorization.", "evidenceLinks": [], "sourceRefs": [ { "location": "../case-study/episode-a/EVIDENCE-PACKET.md", "locator": "#existing-architecture-fragments", "supports": "Supplied architecture identifier and definition." } ], "reviewId": "REV-A-RELATIONSHIPS", "supersedes": null, "sourceId": "I-01", "type": "supports", "targetId": "O-01" }, { "id": "RL-022", "version": 1, "status": "accepted", "owner": "Avery Chen / architecture stewardship", "scope": "Fictional Northstar Episode A decision; accepted for this engagement only.", "effectiveFrom": "2026-01-09", "effectiveTo": null, "reviewDate": "2026-01-30", "accessClass": "public-fictional", "classification": "inference", "confidence": "medium", "confidenceBasis": "Typed bounded inference/design, not causal proof or operating authorization.", "evidenceLinks": [], "sourceRefs": [ { "location": "../case-study/episode-a/EVIDENCE-PACKET.md", "locator": "#existing-architecture-fragments", "supports": "Supplied architecture identifier and definition." } ], "reviewId": "REV-A-RELATIONSHIPS", "supersedes": null, "sourceId": "R1", "type": "depends-on", "targetId": "POL-01" } ], "reviews": [ { "id": "REV-A-ELEMENTS", "targetType": "elements", "targetIds": [ "O-01", "O-02", "O-03", "VS-01", "ST-02", "C-110", "C-130", "C-140", "C-170", "C-180", "BO-02", "BO-05", "BO-06", "I-01", "R1", "M-01", "M-02", "M-03", "M-04", "M-06", "M-07", "M-08", "POL-01" ], "disposition": "accept", "reviewer": "Avery Chen", "reviewerRole": "ORG-14 business architect", "reviewedAt": "2026-01-09T14:00:00Z", "rationale": "Bounded definitions accepted; BO-05 authority unresolved; R1/policy remain design proposals.", "requiredChange": null }, { "id": "REV-A-RELATIONSHIPS", "targetType": "relationships", "targetIds": [ "RL-001", "RL-002", "RL-003", "RL-004", "RL-005", "RL-006", "RL-007", "RL-008", "RL-009", "RL-010", "RL-011", "RL-012", "RL-013", "RL-014", "RL-015", "RL-016", "RL-017", "RL-018", "RL-019", "RL-020", "RL-021", "RL-022" ], "disposition": "accept", "reviewer": "Avery Chen", "reviewerRole": "ORG-14 business architect", "reviewedAt": "2026-01-09T14:00:00Z", "rationale": "Atomic typed relationships accepted as disclosed inference/design, not causal proof.", "requiredChange": null }, { "id": "REV-AN-A-01", "targetType": "analyses", "targetIds": [ "AN-A-01" ], "disposition": "accept", "reviewer": "Avery Chen", "reviewerRole": "ORG-14 business architect", "reviewedAt": "2026-01-09T14:00:00Z", "rationale": "Accept the bounded finding with its limitations.", "requiredChange": null }, { "id": "REV-AN-A-02", "targetType": "analyses", "targetIds": [ "AN-A-02" ], "disposition": "reject", "reviewer": "Avery Chen", "reviewerRole": "ORG-14 business architect", "reviewedAt": "2026-01-09T14:00:00Z", "rationale": "Source does not establish asserted value or representativeness. Preserve this rejection.", "requiredChange": null }, { "id": "REV-AN-A-03", "targetType": "analyses", "targetIds": [ "AN-A-03" ], "disposition": "reject", "reviewer": "Avery Chen", "reviewerRole": "ORG-14 business architect", "reviewedAt": "2026-01-09T14:00:00Z", "rationale": "Source does not establish asserted value or representativeness. Preserve this rejection.", "requiredChange": null }, { "id": "REV-AN-A-04", "targetType": "analyses", "targetIds": [ "AN-A-04" ], "disposition": "accept", "reviewer": "Avery Chen", "reviewerRole": "ORG-14 business architect", "reviewedAt": "2026-01-09T14:00:00Z", "rationale": "Accept the bounded finding with its limitations.", "requiredChange": null }, { "id": "REV-DEC-001", "targetType": "decisions", "targetIds": [ "DEC-001" ], "disposition": "accept", "reviewer": "Jordan Reed", "reviewerRole": "ORG-13 Council chair", "reviewedAt": "2026-01-09T16:00:00Z", "rationale": "Authored fictional decision; SCALE does not supply approval.", "requiredChange": null }, { "id": "REV-DEC-002", "targetType": "decisions", "targetIds": [ "DEC-002" ], "disposition": "accept", "reviewer": "Jordan Reed", "reviewerRole": "ORG-13 Council chair", "reviewedAt": "2026-01-09T16:00:00Z", "rationale": "Authored fictional decision; SCALE does not supply approval.", "requiredChange": null } ], "proposals": [ { "id": "PR-A-01", "kind": "finding", "targetType": "analyses", "targetIds": [ "AN-A-01" ], "statement": "Authorize the up-to-$15k diagnostic now within a conditional A1 envelope; release later tranches only if decision-changing operating uncertainty remains. Assess A4 seriously; defer A3.", "evidenceLinks": [ { "evidenceId": "E-003", "claimId": "E-003.2", "locator": "#e-003 / E-003.2", "supports": "Allocation, reservation, expiry and refresh have distinct meanings." }, { "evidenceId": "E-004", "claimId": "E-004.4", "locator": "#e-004 / E-004.4", "supports": "A4 narrow feed/exception queue: $60–120k, 1–2 FTE, contingent on source semantics; not a scarcity/travel/policy solution." }, { "evidenceId": "E-005", "claimId": "E-005.5", "locator": "#e-005 / E-005.5", "supports": "Resolve decision-changing uncertainty cheaply before material commitment." }, { "evidenceId": "E-007", "claimId": "E-007.1", "locator": "#e-007 / E-007.1", "supports": "Five-day diagnostic within $15k included in eventual A1 cap." }, { "evidenceId": "E-007", "claimId": "E-007.2", "locator": "#e-007 / E-007.2", "supports": "Proposed cumulative stages:$15k diagnostic,$75k preparation,$300k after entry." } ], "classification": "recommendation", "confidence": "medium", "confidenceBasis": "Evidence supports only the bounded assertion; limitations remain visible.", "requiredChange": null, "status": "reviewed", "reviewId": "REV-AN-A-01" }, { "id": "PR-A-02", "kind": "finding", "targetType": "analyses", "targetIds": [ "AN-A-02" ], "statement": "Buying the demonstrated platform will produce the intended service and margin value.", "evidenceLinks": [ { "evidenceId": "E-004", "claimId": "E-004.1", "locator": "#e-004 / E-004.1", "supports": "Demo blocked commitments with absent part/skill fields." }, { "evidenceId": "E-004", "claimId": "E-004.2", "locator": "#e-004 / E-004.2", "supports": "No live feed, representative rural test, adoption or value experiment." } ], "classification": "assumption", "confidence": "insufficient", "confidenceBasis": "Evidence supports only the bounded assertion; limitations remain visible.", "requiredChange": null, "status": "reviewed", "reviewId": "REV-AN-A-02" }, { "id": "PR-A-03", "kind": "finding", "targetType": "analyses", "targetIds": [ "AN-A-03" ], "statement": "Three purposively selected branches establish enterprise repeatability.", "evidenceLinks": [ { "evidenceId": "E-007", "claimId": "E-007.4", "locator": "#e-007 / E-007.4", "supports": "Readiness,customer harm and source authority may stop a test after analysis is sufficient." } ], "classification": "assumption", "confidence": "insufficient", "confidenceBasis": "Evidence supports only the bounded assertion; limitations remain visible.", "requiredChange": null, "status": "reviewed", "reviewId": "REV-AN-A-03" }, { "id": "PR-A-04", "kind": "finding", "targetType": "analyses", "targetIds": [ "AN-A-04" ], "statement": "BO-05 ownership and source authority remain unresolved; the candidate inventory record is not established enterprise authority.", "evidenceLinks": [ { "evidenceId": "E-003", "claimId": "E-003.2", "locator": "#e-003 / E-003.2", "supports": "Allocation, reservation, expiry and refresh have distinct meanings." }, { "evidenceId": "E-003", "claimId": "E-003.5", "locator": "#e-003 / E-003.5", "supports": "Identifiers/timestamps do not establish consistent source semantics." } ], "classification": "unknown", "confidence": "high", "confidenceBasis": "Evidence supports only the bounded assertion; limitations remain visible.", "requiredChange": null, "status": "reviewed", "reviewId": "REV-AN-A-04" } ], "analyses": [ { "id": "AN-A-01", "question": "What is the smallest defensible next commitment to improve customer service-promise reliability?", "statement": "Authorize the up-to-$15k diagnostic now within a conditional A1 envelope; release later tranches only if decision-changing operating uncertainty remains. Assess A4 seriously; defer A3.", "classification": "recommendation", "confidence": "medium", "confidenceBasis": "Evidence supports only the bounded assertion; limitations remain visible.", "scope": "Episode A; no readiness or outcome evidence.", "asOf": "2026-01-09T12:00:00Z", "status": "accepted", "path": [ "O-01", "RL-001", "VS-01", "RL-003", "ST-02", "C-110", "C-140", "BO-05", "I-01", "R1" ], "evidenceLinks": [ { "evidenceId": "E-003", "claimId": "E-003.2", "locator": "#e-003 / E-003.2", "supports": "Allocation, reservation, expiry and refresh have distinct meanings." }, { "evidenceId": "E-004", "claimId": "E-004.4", "locator": "#e-004 / E-004.4", "supports": "A4 narrow feed/exception queue: $60–120k, 1–2 FTE, contingent on source semantics; not a scarcity/travel/policy solution." }, { "evidenceId": "E-005", "claimId": "E-005.5", "locator": "#e-005 / E-005.5", "supports": "Resolve decision-changing uncertainty cheaply before material commitment." }, { "evidenceId": "E-007", "claimId": "E-007.1", "locator": "#e-007 / E-007.1", "supports": "Five-day diagnostic within $15k included in eventual A1 cap." }, { "evidenceId": "E-007", "claimId": "E-007.2", "locator": "#e-007 / E-007.2", "supports": "Proposed cumulative stages:$15k diagnostic,$75k preparation,$300k after entry." } ], "sourceRefs": [], "conflicts": [ "Policy,information,capacity and measurement may contribute differently." ], "implication": "Keep investment,readiness,expansion and procurement separate.", "nextAction": "Named Council and source-owner review.", "reviewId": "REV-AN-A-01", "supersedes": null }, { "id": "AN-A-02", "question": "What is the smallest defensible next commitment to improve customer service-promise reliability?", "statement": "Buying the demonstrated platform will produce the intended service and margin value.", "classification": "assumption", "confidence": "insufficient", "confidenceBasis": "Evidence supports only the bounded assertion; limitations remain visible.", "scope": "Episode A; no readiness or outcome evidence.", "asOf": "2026-01-09T12:00:00Z", "status": "rejected", "path": [ "O-01", "RL-001", "VS-01", "RL-003", "ST-02", "C-110", "C-140", "BO-05", "I-01", "R1" ], "evidenceLinks": [ { "evidenceId": "E-004", "claimId": "E-004.1", "locator": "#e-004 / E-004.1", "supports": "Demo blocked commitments with absent part/skill fields." }, { "evidenceId": "E-004", "claimId": "E-004.2", "locator": "#e-004 / E-004.2", "supports": "No live feed, representative rural test, adoption or value experiment." } ], "sourceRefs": [], "conflicts": [ "Policy,information,capacity and measurement may contribute differently." ], "implication": "Keep investment,readiness,expansion and procurement separate.", "nextAction": "Named Council and source-owner review.", "reviewId": "REV-AN-A-02", "supersedes": null }, { "id": "AN-A-03", "question": "What is the smallest defensible next commitment to improve customer service-promise reliability?", "statement": "Three purposively selected branches establish enterprise repeatability.", "classification": "assumption", "confidence": "insufficient", "confidenceBasis": "Evidence supports only the bounded assertion; limitations remain visible.", "scope": "Episode A; no readiness or outcome evidence.", "asOf": "2026-01-09T12:00:00Z", "status": "rejected", "path": [ "O-01", "RL-001", "VS-01", "RL-003", "ST-02", "C-110", "C-140", "BO-05", "I-01", "R1" ], "evidenceLinks": [ { "evidenceId": "E-007", "claimId": "E-007.4", "locator": "#e-007 / E-007.4", "supports": "Readiness,customer harm and source authority may stop a test after analysis is sufficient." } ], "sourceRefs": [], "conflicts": [ "Policy,information,capacity and measurement may contribute differently." ], "implication": "Keep investment,readiness,expansion and procurement separate.", "nextAction": "Named Council and source-owner review.", "reviewId": "REV-AN-A-03", "supersedes": null }, { "id": "AN-A-04", "question": "What is the smallest defensible next commitment to improve customer service-promise reliability?", "statement": "BO-05 ownership and source authority remain unresolved; the candidate inventory record is not established enterprise authority.", "classification": "unknown", "confidence": "high", "confidenceBasis": "Evidence supports only the bounded assertion; limitations remain visible.", "scope": "Episode A; no readiness or outcome evidence.", "asOf": "2026-01-09T12:00:00Z", "status": "accepted", "path": [ "O-01", "RL-001", "VS-01", "RL-003", "ST-02", "C-110", "C-140", "BO-05", "I-01", "R1" ], "evidenceLinks": [ { "evidenceId": "E-003", "claimId": "E-003.2", "locator": "#e-003 / E-003.2", "supports": "Allocation, reservation, expiry and refresh have distinct meanings." }, { "evidenceId": "E-003", "claimId": "E-003.5", "locator": "#e-003 / E-003.5", "supports": "Identifiers/timestamps do not establish consistent source semantics." } ], "sourceRefs": [], "conflicts": [ "Policy,information,capacity and measurement may contribute differently." ], "implication": "Keep investment,readiness,expansion and procurement separate.", "nextAction": "Named Council and source-owner review.", "reviewId": "REV-AN-A-04", "supersedes": null } ], "decisions": [ { "id": "DEC-001", "type": "decision", "statement": "Conditionally authorize A1 within $150–300k, with $15k diagnostic,$75k cumulative preparation and $300k total cap; operational entry remains separate.", "owner": "Jordan Reed / ORG-13 Investment Council", "decidedAt": "2026-01-09T16:00:00Z", "conditions": [ "Include branch participation and measurement.", "Review what would make A0/A4 or stopping preferable.", "Approve policy,definitions,owner/source status,branch selection and readiness before activation." ], "rationale": "Preserve options and resolve decision-relevant uncertainty before larger commitment.", "evidenceLinks": [ { "evidenceId": "E-005", "claimId": "E-005.5", "locator": "#e-005 / E-005.5", "supports": "Resolve decision-changing uncertainty cheaply before material commitment." }, { "evidenceId": "E-007", "claimId": "E-007.1", "locator": "#e-007 / E-007.1", "supports": "Five-day diagnostic within $15k included in eventual A1 cap." }, { "evidenceId": "E-007", "claimId": "E-007.2", "locator": "#e-007 / E-007.2", "supports": "Proposed cumulative stages:$15k diagnostic,$75k preparation,$300k after entry." } ], "affectedArchitectureIds": [ "R1", "I-01", "BO-05", "POL-01" ], "status": "active", "reviewDate": "2026-01-30", "reviewTrigger": "New diagnostic,readiness,scope,cost,capacity or residual-gap evidence.", "expiresAt": null, "reviewId": "REV-DEC-001", "supersedes": null }, { "id": "DEC-002", "type": "decision", "statement": "Defer A3. Reopen only with repeatability and measured residual gaps supporting a separate comparison of integration,workflow,platform and nontechnology options.", "owner": "Jordan Reed / ORG-13 Investment Council", "decidedAt": "2026-01-09T16:00:00Z", "conditions": [ "Vendor functionality alone is insufficient.", "A4 remains a comparator contingent on source meaning and burden." ], "rationale": "Preserve options and resolve decision-relevant uncertainty before larger commitment.", "evidenceLinks": [ { "evidenceId": "E-004", "claimId": "E-004.1", "locator": "#e-004 / E-004.1", "supports": "Demo blocked commitments with absent part/skill fields." }, { "evidenceId": "E-004", "claimId": "E-004.2", "locator": "#e-004 / E-004.2", "supports": "No live feed, representative rural test, adoption or value experiment." }, { "evidenceId": "E-004", "claimId": "E-004.4", "locator": "#e-004 / E-004.4", "supports": "A4 narrow feed/exception queue: $60–120k, 1–2 FTE, contingent on source semantics; not a scarcity/travel/policy solution." } ], "affectedArchitectureIds": [ "I-01" ], "status": "active", "reviewDate": "2026-05-06", "reviewTrigger": "New diagnostic,readiness,scope,cost,capacity or residual-gap evidence.", "expiresAt": null, "reviewId": "REV-DEC-002", "supersedes": null } ], "openItems": [ { "id": "OI-02", "type": "missing-owner", "description": "Confirm BO-05 owner and bounded source status.", "consequence": "Candidate inventory record may be misrepresented as enterprise authority.", "owner": "ORG-08 / ORG-10", "requiredAction": "Record owner and source conditions before R1.", "dueDate": "2026-01-30", "status": "open", "closedAt": null, "resolution": null, "relatedIds": [ "BO-05", "DEC-001" ] }, { "id": "OI-03", "type": "conflict", "description": "Reconcile original/latest promise,cancellations and repeat-visit coding.", "consequence": "Apparent improvement may reflect denominator or definition change.", "owner": "ORG-09 / ORG-07 / ORG-12", "requiredAction": "Preserve transparent comparable customer-facing measures.", "dueDate": "2026-01-30", "status": "open", "closedAt": null, "resolution": null, "relatedIds": [ "M-01", "M-02" ] }, { "id": "OI-05", "type": "review", "description": "Review whether diagnostic warrants A1,A4,smaller response or stopping.", "consequence": "Learning could become a pretext to spend the full cap.", "owner": "Jordan Reed / ORG-13", "requiredAction": "Approve the next useful commitment after diagnostic.", "dueDate": "2026-01-30", "status": "open", "closedAt": null, "resolution": null, "relatedIds": [ "DEC-001", "R1" ] } ], "maintenance": [ { "id": "MAINT-01", "architectureIds": [ "BO-02", "BO-05", "C-110", "C-170", "POL-01" ], "governingSource": "Northstar learning edition1.2; bounded source-owner dispositions.", "steward": "Avery Chen", "reviewTrigger": "New readiness/results; changed promise semantics,ownership,guards or scope.", "reviewDate": "2026-01-30", "reuseScenarios": [ "Readiness", "Day30/90 review", "R2 decision" ], "retirementCondition": "Supersede when scope,ownership or source authority ceases to apply." } ], "history": [ { "id": "H-A-01", "recordedAt": "2026-01-09T17:00:00Z", "actor": "Avery Chen", "targetType": "workspace", "targetIds": [ "WS-NORTHSTAR" ], "action": "created", "rationale": "Authored fictional reference answer. Later evidence not yet supplied.", "priorExportId": null, "changes": [] } ], "continuation": { "nextQuestion": "Does readiness evidence justify R1 activation under DEC-001?", "requiredEvidence": [ "E-008 when available." ], "reviewsDue": [ "Source/owner,policy,measure,customer-outcome and diagnostic-tranche review." ], "reusableIds": [ "O-01", "O-02", "O-03", "VS-01", "ST-02", "C-110", "C-140", "BO-05", "R1" ], "notCurrentIds": [ "AN-A-02", "AN-A-03" ], "disposition": "continue", "instructions": [ "Load Episode B only at readiness.", "Preserve A findings and rejected claims with their original asOf dates.", "A named human records readiness; SCALE cannot activate." ] } }